Op-Ed: In Shipbuilding, Don\u2019t Confuse Efficiency with Effectiveness
\n \t
\n
<\/BR>
\n
\n \t
\n
<\/BR><\/p>\n
\u00a0<\/p>\n
We often hear the terms used interchangeably, but\u00a0doing things right\u00a0(efficiency) is not the same as\u00a0doing the right things (effectiveness). True success in complex industries like shipbuilding and maritime operations demands alignment between the two. Yet in practice, that alignment is rarely achieved and often confused as one driving the other.<\/p>\n
Focusing on data, as leaders we track cost-per-unit, man-hour ratios, and schedule milestones and while these are important, these are\u00a0known process metrics, not\u00a0outcome indicators. It\u2019s entirely possible to deliver a ship \u201con time and on budget\u201d and still fail the mission if it can\u2019t sail, can\u2019t be maintained, or is delivered to an understaffed fleet.<\/p>\n
Below are three common traps that erode effectiveness, even in the pursuit of efficiency.<\/p>\n
It\u2019s Not the Talent. It\u2019s the Team.<\/em><\/strong><\/p>\n A Chief Engineer once told me, \u201cIf I just had better trained people, I could finally fix this place.\u201d Any Sailor worth their salt knows: it takes more than individual competence to get a complex system working. It takes a functioning team. While training is important, individuals can win a battle, but teams win wars.<\/p>\n Effective leadership isn\u2019t about cherry-picking talent; it\u2019s about cultivating\u00a0team effectiveness. Building trust, purpose, and cohesion, that\u2019s where sustained productivity is born. Once you\u2019ve built the team,\u00a0then\u00a0you can drive efficiencies. Forming, storming, norming, performing\u2026 and yes, reiterating the cycle. For those that recognize the quote, \u201cIt gets easier. Every day it gets a little easier. But you gotta do it every day. That\u2019s the hard part.\u201d<\/p>\n It isn\u2019t dollars that make cents. It is dollars that make sense.<\/em><\/strong><\/p>\n Despite the Navy doubling its shipbuilding budget over the last 20 years, fleet size has flatlined and our known problems have exacerbated. In 2024, the GAO reported up to\u00a03-year delays\u00a0in ship deliveries and an\u00a0estimated 46% (known) shortfall in effective output per dollar spent, adjusted for inflation.<\/p>\n Why? Because money alone doesn\u2019t build ships.<\/p>\n Two structural issues remain unaddressed (as noted in the same report):<\/p>\n Ask any economist or professional estimator:\u00a0appropriations without investment in people and capacity don\u2019t solve the problem, they just inflate the baseline in cascading estimates and award.<\/p>\n Conglomeration Chokes Competition<\/em><\/strong><\/p>\n The U.S. maritime sector, like many industries of our economy, has quietly consolidated into a few mega-firms. In the case of Navy shipbuilding, reduced competition has resulted in an extreme case; a\u00a0non-functional duopoly:<\/p>\n That leaves just\u00a010\u201315%\u00a0of the market to all remaining players combined (Fincantieri, Austal USA, Bollinger, and Vigor (Titan)). As Rear Admiral Matt Lake recently put it best, we face entrenched \u201cbarriers to entry, lack of a supplier ecosystem, and monopolistic practices born of decades of consolidation.\u201d<\/p>\n This isn\u2019t just about cost, it\u2019s about capacity, agility, and resilience. A market of two cannot surge, innovate, or adapt fast enough to meet today\u2019s threats.<\/p>\n So, What Now?<\/em><\/strong><\/p>\n We have the talent. We\u2019ve diagnosed the problems. We need action.<\/p>\n Policymakers must distinguish\u00a0effectiveness\u00a0from\u00a0efficiency\u00a0and stop mistaking full budgets for full readiness (of which we have neither, but that is another post). The maritime sector is not just about ships, it\u2019s about national security, economic mobility, and industrial leadership. China now commands\u00a051% of global shipbuilding; the U.S. needs more than spreadsheets to compete.<\/p>\n Never one to follow but a country that leads, we must:<\/p>\n Make no mistake, none of this is easy. But if we are serious, and I believe we are, that\u2019s how we restore strength to America\u2019s shipbuilding backbone.<\/p>\n See you on the deck plate<\/p>\n Benjamin Miner is a licensed professional mariner with more than 25 years in industry, both at sea and on shore. He has been a resident of Hampton Roads since 2017, where he lives with his wife and son.<\/em><\/p>\n<\/div>\n \t\n
\n
\n
\n
<\/BR><\/p>\n